HardAssetsInvestor

Written by Julian Murdoch  |

November 06, 2008

Digging Into Shipping

Details

Shipping rates could be the worst-performing commodity index in the market, but does that mean it's time to buy?

• The shipping company trading range
• How to read a quarterly report
• Top shippers compared

 

The Baltic Dry Index (previous articles: The Baltic Bet, 9/16/08 and Follow The Freight, 4/28/08) has taken a beating, as have shipping stocks. But are the two as directly linked as it seems? Or is it possible that shipping stocks, like so many commodities equities, could be undervalued right now?

 

 

The Baltic Dry Index (BDI) has lost an amazing 90% of its value since the beginning of the year, and is 93% off the highs of May and June.

As we explained in The Baltic Bet, shipping rates are tracked primarily by the Baltic Dry Index, a blending of the rates to ship bulk dry goods (largely ores and grain) on three different-sized boats on the four main shipping routes. The BDI gives you a good idea of what the spot price is for hiring a ship, and as such, serves as an indicator for supply and demand. The current low level of the index (and this, the spot price) tells you that demand for dry bulk vessels is unbelievably low. This means that somewhere there are lots of enormous ships lying around in ports. Either because there are literally no charters to be had, or more often, the day rate simply isn't high enough to even offset a voyage's expenses, much less turn a profit.

All the things that make a boat go cost money - crew salaries, provisions, lubrication costs - and no company wants to pay for a pleasure cruise when the vessel should be making money. It's worth pointing out that the pressures involved here aren't always easy to tease out from the shipping companies themselves. Eighty percent of the global dry bulk fleet is privately held, and according to Forbes, anecdotal rumors are supporting the idea that many of these private vessels are anchored, rather than operating at low spot rates.

It would stand to reason that shipping companies would be in dire straits with the BDI so low, and at first glance, the company/BDI tie looks dramatically connected.

 

 

OK, clear as mud. Normally I wouldn't comment on (or even post) an anti-Tufte mass of indecipherable lines like the one above, but it does illustrate one thing - while the companies trend up and down together, they live in an implied trading range where there's plenty of money to be made.

 

Making Money

Let's tease out a few companies.

 

 

Shipping companies charter their vessels out a few different ways - spot charters, time charters and "bareboat" charters. In both spot and time charters, the boat's owners are usually responsible for operating expenses such as crew costs, provisions, lubricating oil, insurance, maintenance, dry-docking and repairs. The difference is that in a spot charter, the owners are also responsible for any voyage expenses such as port fees and fuel costs, because a spot charter is generally limited to a specific voyage or delivery - take my wheat to China, stat! In a time charter, the boat owner doesn't care about the intended use. The person chartering the ship handles voyage expenses, because the contract is for a specified time period, which can be years in length. It's kind of like the difference between taking a cab downtown and renting your limo for the prom.