|
The crude oil market has slipped again into full-blown backwardation (f or an explanation of backwardation, see "The Battle Against Contango"), pointing to the pervasive tight-supply mentality held by traders.
It's been a month (see "Check Your Oil Lately?,") since we last took a dipstick to the market to gauge oil-based ETFs' and ETNs' market tracking.
Last month, The United States Oil Fund (AMEX: USO) took top honors in the return department, bettering the gains earned by its then-new cousin, the United States 12-Month Oil Fund (AMEX: USL).
USO tracks the price movements of West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude oil by using the nearby NYMEX futures contract, while USL's price movements are based upon an equally weighted average of the nearest 12 NYMEX delivery months.
Oil Check
USL and USO are pretty evenly matched now, though the lower beta of the older-style USO portfolio yields more alpha. The more interesting story, though, is the continuing underperformance of the PowerShares DB Oil ETF (AMEX: DBO).
Oil Portfolios Vs. West Texas Intermediate (WTI) Spot
|
|
USL
|
USO
|
OIL
|
DBO
|
WTI
|
|
Compound Annual Growth Rate
|
73.50%
|
73.54%
|
74.08%
|
53.84%
|
66.18%
|
|
r-Squared
|
.54
|
.94
|
.94
|
.79
|
--
|
|
Beta
|
1.15
|
1.01
|
.99
|
1.12
|
--
|
|
Alpha
|
-.02
|
.07
|
.09
|
-.20
|
--
|
|
Sharpe Ratio
|
2.88
|
2.48
|
2.56
|
1.79
|
2.14
|
And it's that we'll look at next ...
|